Description
As some of you know, I struggle with chronic depression. I’ve been seeing a therapist for over five years now, and it’s helped a lot, but depression is not really something you can “just get over.” It’s more like a permanent wound that you learn how to mitigate and survive. Being a creative person with depression has its own hurdles, as many of the routine tasks of making art can be appropriated by depression and used to reinforce a negative core belief. Today I want to talk a little bit about how that manifests for me, and some things I try to keep in mind that have been helpful, in hopes that others may benefit from it. It’s easy to feel isolated and alone when depressed, as though no one else experiences these kinds of things and feeling depression is a weakness of character. Neither of those things are true. We are survivors. The only reason we’re still here is because we are strong.
A Negative Core Belief & The Arts What is a negative core belief? Well…most people that I’ve met perceive themselves in some positive light. They believe that they are, at their core, a good person. A positive core belief. Having a negative core means that at best, I perceive myself as a bad person. At worst, I perceive my own identity as an aching sensation of broken emptiness. When in a depressive low, the perspective is narrowed and exaggerated to reinforce that belief.
To improve as an artist, it’s important to identify areas for improvement, accept feedback, and learn to express the truth of our own experiences as much as possible. What depression will do is take these activities and twist them. Aspects that need improvement become to my mind evidence of incompetence, laziness, and stupidity. Furthermore, I will feel these flaws are unchangeable and eternal. Not because I am incapable, but because there is something wrong and broken about me that prevents me from ever being good enough to realize my potential. That if I wasn’t so weak and pathetic, everything I want for myself would be instantly achieved. Outside criticism only reaffirms this belief, and instead of being able to utilize useful and specific critique, I will fixate on vague comments that my mind can twist to feed that negative core belief. A comment like, “The style isn’t very pro,” can get blown out of proportion to the point that my mind takes it as evidence that my ambition will always out-strip my talent, and that everything I attempt will end in failure.
Sometimes depression can even block the creation of art, because the emotion I’m trying to access is triggering. As a result, I encounter blocks due to the stress, lethargy, and despair depression brings on. This makes me feel as though I’m taking too long, that I’m not working hard enough, and I will blame myself for my lack of progress. This in turn only increases the difficulty in getting the work done. It’s a nasty cycle. However, it is not a cycle that is impossible to change.
Strategies to Cultivate
Developing coping strategies is a constant effort. Many have cumulative, rather than instant, impact. Which means that the first time many of them are attempted, they may not have any clear effect at all. However, I have found that slowly, piece by piece, these strategies have contributed to the emergence of a small, but ever growing, positive core. It has not replaced the negative core belief, but rather stands next to it as a contrast. Having it there has changed how I experience and endure depressive episodes.
1. Respecting the Necessity of Time and the Inevitability of Change
Being depressed often feels like being suspended in an eternal, stagnant, hopeless moment. If I’m not successful NOW, I feel as though I never will be. I remind myself that art, life, and learning are all a process, not an end goal. That mistakes and setbacks are inevitable when attempting anything, as that is a major part of how humans learn. If anything, a mistake is something to celebrate, as it indicates that I am DOING something and trying something new. Which means I’m cultivating a new skill, and will get better, given time and practice. No “Now” is permanent. No day lasts forever. Nothing will remain unchanged.
2. Compassion and Self Care – How would you treat a friend?
When I’m down, I often put my own needs at the bottom of my list of priorities. Eating, sleeping, hygiene. If I feel like I’m not a person, then what need is there to take care of me? Am I worthy of such kind treatment, of a soft bed, of a meal, or a hot shower? Except, as common sense tells us, it’s really hard to feel good about anything at all when you’re tired, hungry, and your own odor repels you. Add to that all the depression voices constantly berating me, and it becomes a very ugly picture. I’ve learned to ask myself, “If a friend was feeling the way I feel, how would I treat them?” Then I try to treat myself as though I were that imagined friend in need. (Hint: It usually involves a lot more sleep and soup, and a lot less tirades on what a horrible disappointment I am.)
3. Becoming an Investigator
Depressive lows are not states of mind that can be solved with a forced smile, thinking happy thoughts, finding silver linings, or employing distractions. Sometimes the best that can be done is to just ride the wave until the mood has run its course. However, that does not mean I have to be helpless. Attempting to force happiness creates a situation where I am at war with myself, and often prolongs the depressive low. Becoming a neutral observer, on the other hand, provides me useful information for next time without interfering with, repressing, or invalidating my present experience. I try to trace back to what triggered a mood and observe patterns of thoughts and behaviors. Sometimes I might reflect on past situations and find connections. Or perhaps I’ll evaluate if there are any physical symptoms of the mood, depression “Tells,” that might help me identify triggering incidents in the future. All of it is useful information for developing future strategies and helps cultivate a self-aware mindset. I have found that becoming an Investigator of my own depression has been one of the most effective tools in transforming it. I can now often recognize when I’m going to have a low in advance. In some cases, mitigate it or prevent it all together. When I am in a low, I’m better able to articulate how I’m feeling and communicate to loved ones what I need. I can often separate thoughts that are based on the negative-core-belief from the realities of a situation, giving me valuable perspective that makes it easier to take care of myself despite a major low. And no matter how bad it gets, when I can remember to act as an Investigator, it makes it feel as though even that horrible experience has value. That I’m still learning something. It gives the process a meaning and purpose, where otherwise there would be only emptiness.
I hope that some of these strategies are helpful to any LeyLines readers that also struggle with depression. You’re not alone. I know that my experience is likely different than yours, and that what works for me may not be the same as what works for you, but we do share some common experiences. You’re a good person. WE are good people. Hopefully one day we can both believe that, in our core.
Comments: 31
SephirothsFlamedWing [2014-02-11 19:38:52 +0000 UTC]
I can totally understand where you're coming from here, especially about the part where you know something in your mind to be true, but it doesn't feel true. I've never understood what it was like to have a positive self-image. It always seemed to me that people with a positive self-image weren't looking at themselves very closely, but then again, I tend to be pretty cynical and curmudgeonly.
I was diagnosed with clinical depression when I was younger, but I honestly think it was more of a situational thing for me. That, and it was easier for my psychologist to throw pills at me than to try to understand what I was saying. Once I got out of the bad situation, I wasn't so focused on the sadness and misery and need to escape. Unfortunately, the self-contempt and self-loathing decided to stick around, along with all my extremely dysfunctional coping mechanisms. For me, that inner voice just tells me to shut up and deal with it alone, sometimes to the point where I can't even bring myself to share my opinions because, honestly, who really cares what I have to say, anyway? That same voice tells me that emotions are weakness and I've been pretty well conditioned not to show weakness, ever. It's interesting to see how other people cope with their issues, even if I can't really replicate them.
Anyway, getting to the point- I probably don't need to tell you this, but the fact that you have people in your life who care is a good thing. From the outside looking in, I can tell you that there are people who care about you. Even when you feel like they're only saying things to make you feel better, the fact that they still want to make you feel better shows they do care. Sometimes we have to realize that our self-perception can be just as distorted and tinted with prejudices as anyone's, and just because we live in our own heads doesn't necessarily mean we know ourselves as we truly are. I'm no good at comforting stuff- the things I say tend to be borderline cruel when I try to make things better, so I won't try for any uplifting commentary here. But having a support network is a good thing for those who can have one.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to SephirothsFlamedWing [2014-02-11 20:31:21 +0000 UTC]
In the end, I think depression is entirely all those maladaptive coping mechanisms. None of us are as alone as we might believe, or as terrible as we think. We can be connected, we can receive help, our emotions can make us strong, and we all have something valuable to share with the world. The more aware we become of all the inner voices and coping mechanisms that say otherwise, the more agency we can develop to create another truth.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
RobinRone In reply to SilverSomnium [2013-11-16 02:15:50 +0000 UTC]
You're very welcome. It felt important to share.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
soupPlz [2013-11-12 23:58:29 +0000 UTC]
That's beautiful
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to soupPlz [2013-11-13 00:18:21 +0000 UTC]
Thank you. I'm glad you think so.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
ElectricGecko [2013-11-09 03:01:47 +0000 UTC]
I suffer from the opposite problem: being largely happy yet shallow. My art has suffered because of it.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to ElectricGecko [2013-11-09 05:35:37 +0000 UTC]
Pain isn't a requirement for good art. Truth is. You can share the true heights of joy in your experience. That's just as valid as the depths of my depression. Frankly, the world could use a little more joy. Access the truth of it, the heart of it, and I have every confidence that your art will be full of depth.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ElectricGecko In reply to RobinRone [2013-11-09 11:16:41 +0000 UTC]
A wise observation. My favourite artistic kindred spirit is Ovid. He loved life, and he loved his life, and he rejoiced in that through his work. Then he got banished to a barbarian-infested town at the edges of civilization on the Black Sea. Ouch. The odd thing with him was that suffering totally quashed his artistic flair. He kept writing, but it was mostly just whining about how his life sucked.
I have the deepest respect for you and your ability to ford through the dark waters and craft things of beauty. We're all the richer for it.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
emteaART [2013-11-09 01:21:06 +0000 UTC]
It's quite inspirational that you're talking so openly about this and not just to wallow in self-pity or anything like it, but as something a challenge to overcome and an experience to share with other people who are not yet sure how to fight their demons.
Anyway, as I said sometime before, I don't know how is it to have a depression, but effects of neurosis seem to be similar and after reading enough material about it, it's quite apparent that some kind of neurotic disorder keeps chewing at my brain. Last week was especially horrendous, especially after PMS kicked in, leaving me mentally and physically strained to the point of being nearly entirely dysfunctional. I think it's about time to stop guessing and just vising a few specialists. Maybe then things will start to change and I'll be finally able to become more active and helpful, rather than lurking and impotently whining about things >_<
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to emteaART [2013-11-09 05:38:13 +0000 UTC]
I would definitely encourage anyone that struggles to seek help. It's not a sign of weakness, but of strength. Taking action to address mental illness is taking action to reclaim one's life.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
RobinRone In reply to Pirate-Jenny [2013-11-09 05:40:50 +0000 UTC]
That's part of why I shared them. They may not be a solution for everyone, but if they're helpful for just a single someone, then that can make all the difference. There's hope for everyone. That I believe.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
ScottStory [2013-11-08 20:47:17 +0000 UTC]
Robin, you are a very insightful person. Of course, being insightful and understanding the issue doesn't make it any easier, I know.
Listen, I won't drop a bunch of useless platitudes on you--we've both heard them all, I'm sure.
I've been pretty heavily medicated for depression since I was 24, half my life ago, and I've had counseling quite a few times. I used to be hushed up about my problem, but I figured 1) I'm really not fooling people, and 2)my lack of honesty is not helping anyone. You've given far too many tells on your podcast for my to be surprised.
But, I think there is good news. I've learned quite a few tactics to remain mostly functional, and as the years have gone buy I've gotten better at dealing with it, if not outright controlling it. So, at 48, I am still an avid creator, still in a loving and fantastic relationship, and still quite ambitious about my cartooning and art career. You strike me as a very intelligent person (much more so than me, I'm sure), so I am quite sure you will never give up the good fight. I believe you will prevail, because the alternative is no alternative at all.
Let me know if I an be of any assistance. That's very forward of me, but I believe you understand my good intentions.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to ScottStory [2013-11-09 05:42:51 +0000 UTC]
I've already noticed it changing, particularly in the past two years, but right now it's becoming far more intense, even if the episodes are shorter. Sometimes they're just baffling. Hearing that with practice the coping skills can become more and more effective is a great relief. And thank you so much for the offer of help. I understand the intent with which it was given. I've made similar offers to folks too. Like I said, it's important to know that we're not alone.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ScottStory In reply to RobinRone [2013-11-10 00:31:44 +0000 UTC]
I'm glad you understand. Ultimately, we do make this journey alone, but then there are times when some kind words can make all the difference. Besides the medication, the technique that has helped me most has been thought replacement or thought deferral. Well, that and sufficient sleep to restore seratonin. I keep hearing of approaches and try most of them, keeping the good ones. And, again, I'm glad you've decided to share with your readers. You honestly never know when the right words might reach the right people.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
RobinRone In reply to JennOkami [2013-11-09 05:52:21 +0000 UTC]
I struggle with that voice too. Lately, every time I'm asked a "What do you want to do?" or "How should we solve this?" kind of question, that voice barges in and tells me some specific way I could kill myself to make things better. It's frustrating, oppressive, and above all, tiring. I try to let Cory know, now, and I ask him when it happens just to repeat some simple phrases:
"You are a good person."
"You are worthy of love."
"You are strong. You have gotten through this before and you will again."
Most of the time, I respond with "No, I'm not," or the voice will say, "He only says that because you told him to," but those kind and simple phrases have a way of seeping in over time. Part of me is even starting to believe them, now.
...So while I am at it, let me remind you that you are a good person, worthy of love, and that you are strong. Thank you for staying a part of this world. You're a very wonderful part of it, and it would be a much smaller place if you were gone.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
ElwenAldalinde [2013-11-08 15:19:20 +0000 UTC]
Robin, you're an inspiration to us all. I can definitely relate with pieces and parts of what you wrote about, especially the negative core. I'll have days where everything is fine and dandy, and days where an offhanded comment from someone gets into my mind like a virus and eventually brings me to my knees. I've got a mum and brother that I suspect have chronic depression, but unfortunately they won't have anything to do with counseling or therapy. Thank you for sharing this, Robin, I think it will help me come to understand myself and my mum and brother better during those low times.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to ElwenAldalinde [2013-11-09 05:56:28 +0000 UTC]
It can be particularly to address mental illness when your family also suffers from it (although that's fairly typical). Particularly since it's very difficult work to do without a strong support structure, and family is often thought of as being what a person is "supposed to" rely on. Often trying to address mental illness on a personal level will be fought by family members that also suffer from it, as they may rely on those patterns and find someone breaking step very threatening. It's a very tricky situation, and every case has to be handled with care. However, in some situations one person breaking the cycle can be the catalyst for growth in the entire family. And that's a pretty beautiful thing.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
SineSquared [2013-11-08 13:13:00 +0000 UTC]
That's brave of you to share all of this! And that is some excellent advice for other sufferers.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to SineSquared [2013-11-09 05:57:52 +0000 UTC]
Part of my depression used to manifest in hiding the condition, so it's very important to me now to be open about it. Patterns like these can't thrive as well under bright lights. I hope that my experience can be helpful to others that have felt as I do.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
TheBuggiest [2013-11-08 13:03:19 +0000 UTC]
At the risk of sounding like I missed the point entirely, this is kind of fascinating. Just hearing about the struggles another person has, I mean, how they contrast with my own and all. Dunno that there's anything constructive for me to say though.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to TheBuggiest [2013-11-09 05:47:35 +0000 UTC]
I don't think you missed the point at all. Everybody is different. By studying each other we can find new solutions, new ideas, common ground, and points of comparison.
I have a friend who's anorexic. Cory and I attended a lot of group support meetings with them and the other people at the clinic. What struck me the most was how similar my experience was to theirs. The biggest difference was I used art as a coping mechanism, where their eating disorder served as theirs. It made me realize that people can have very different responses to things, but in the end most of them stem from the same basic problems. Being invalidated. Feeling worthless. Having a negative core. How that manifests varies a lot, but in the end we're all human. We all have some things in common.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0
Khyansaria In reply to RobinRone [2013-11-09 14:02:52 +0000 UTC]
Not really, but thank you.
Let me know if there's ever anything I can do for you.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
RobinRone In reply to Khyansaria [2013-11-09 17:05:05 +0000 UTC]
You may not think so, but I think so. I shall not be changing my opinion on you being wonderful. Because it is an empirical observation I have made over a great deal of time. So, if ever you feel less than wonderful, please understand that my feelings and thoughts on the matter will have remained unchanged.
And I will let you know. Please think of me in return if you need anything.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0