Comments: 8
Naznomarn [2011-07-05 07:17:15 +0000 UTC]
I'm British. Forgive me for not celebrating us getting our arses kicked ;D
btw, nice drawing
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
Naznomarn In reply to kamaki-chan [2011-07-08 11:26:52 +0000 UTC]
Nothing wrong with socialism :3
It's just that it only really works if you have everything controlled by a computer ;D
"Those capable of coming to power, should under no circumstance be allowed to wield it" socialism is about giving all the power to the state. And thus in the power of one person / organisation.
If power corrupts, then absolute power corrupts absolutely
The problem is that socialism cannot separate the problem between self interests and the interest of everyone.
To come to power, one must be an egotist and want power. But to be a good leader of a socialist state, one must want the power for other people and that's a trait that leaders rarely have.
It does interest me the way the USA has such a distaste for socialism - despite having a lot of it going on, and were the socialist aspects removed, people would be quite upset. For instance if the government disbanded all state services e.g. got rid of the police force, and made people pay every time the New Police (TM) came to aid them, and if they couldn't pay, the New Police (TM) would leave them to the mercy of the mugger.
Or even worse - if it were left to locally organised militias and witch hunts.
But "spreading the wealth around"... yes. It's a nice idea. But really what that phrase means is "give the debt to the poor people, and the profit to the rich".
Which isn't exactly Robin Hood
At the moment Greece is ready to go down the pan (I think they're in about $45,000 a head debt).
And yes, unless we go out of our way to study American History at University, we don't do the American revolution. We had our revolution centuries ago, and decided we didn't like it
Plus, it was when we got our butts unroyally kicked But also because we've had an empire that covered the majority of the world. At the time, one less country that was a pain to manage was probably a good thing for us
So yes, it's a very minor event for us.
You should try reading War and Peace (I think that's the one). It's a fine example of the kind of history we've had to put up with
Very soap-operatic.
Oh, and apologies for my rambling I like to do that.
👍: 0 ⏩: 1
kamaki-chan In reply to Naznomarn [2011-07-13 00:10:11 +0000 UTC]
Hahaha yeah, socialism is more of an ideal than anything.
We generally don't like socialism (well, half of us. The other half supports it. This country is so divided ) because it doesn't work well. We were taught to believe that if you work hard, you can be whatever you want. But socialism is where the government takes away the money you worked hard for to give to someone else, believing that it is 'fair'. But since the government is not God, there is no way to know who deserves what. And if you're gonna work your butt off for money that's just gonna be taken away for someone who doesn't care or work at all, why should you work then? The incentive to work lowers, and eventually everyone stops working, believing the government will take care of them. And then it collapses. A nation doesn't run on people who don't work.
And I believe that having the police force provided is in the Constitution under the 10th amendment....but I'd have to look further into it. Also the 2nd amendment allows us the right to bear arms...but I think this is being disputed over as well.
And I don't really understand your statement here:
'But "spreading the wealth around"... yes. It's a nice idea. But really what that phrase means is "give the debt to the poor people, and the profit to the rich".
Which isn't exactly Robin Hood '
From what's going on over here, people believe that taxing the rich will solve all our problems. But what's really going on, is the middle class being taxed. We can't support all these taxes.
You know, I've read and reread this a few times, and I still can't figure out what your views are haha. It sounds like you like the idea, but believe it doesn't work. So I'm not really sure what you're trying to get at? :/
And no problem for the rambling! Sorry this took a while, traveling is exhausting. And I'll definitely look into the book!
👍: 0 ⏩: 0