sumghai In reply to Tiberius47 [2014-03-16 22:05:56 +0000 UTC]
I'm quite aware of the use of bio-neural gel packs in canon, especially in relatively new vessels like the Intrepid and Sovereign-classes. Indeed, their performance has been shown to surpass that of traditional Isolinear circuitry.
However, at the end of the day they are still technically biologically-based components highly susceptible infection by bacterial and viral vectors, and thus they are very difficult to maintain at optimal condition. Additionally, replacement gel packs cannot be fabricated using standard replicators. As such, I would imagine that even by the 25th Century Starfleet would opt for a mix of both bio-neural packs and isolinear subprocessors, with the former being relegated to non-mission critical tasks (or at least having isolinear-based backups).
Also, these isolinear chips can be traded or passed around easily as portable storage devices (hence the "flash drive" mentioned in the description). Trading around big wet sacks of neurons can be quite inconvenient, innit?
👍: 1 ⏩: 1
sumghai In reply to Tiberius47 [2014-03-17 05:50:57 +0000 UTC]
I don't see why one needs to implant bio-neural components inside isolinear chips - given the rough handling involved when using such chips, the biological bits are susceptible to irreparable damage.
In short, a ship's computer core and mission critical subsystems should be based purely on isolinear technology, as they are more robust and easily replaced. Bioneural packs are best relegated to non-critical or auxiliary roles. It's rather foolish to have a starship completely dependent on bio-neural packs.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0