NinjaHeart In reply to NinjaHeart [2012-10-16 04:43:26 +0000 UTC]
Well, as per usual, time to nitpick the grammar mistakes! xP just kidding, you know I only do this because I love this story.
"They'd be able smother almost any light"
TO smother.
XXX
"They nodded.."
Did you plan to put an ellipsis there? If not, I don't think there should be two periods...
XXX
"There is something there, in those eyes of hers that I find quite unsettling. But it is not for me to say, she has provided me with room and board until my memory can be regained, I have no place for criticism next to such a generous offer."
Something about those sentences seems off, like they could be broken up better. The way I read it, I think it would sound better like this:
"There is something in her eyes that I find quite unsettling--but it is not for me to say. She has provided me with room and board until my memory can be regained, and I have no place for criticism next to such a generous offer."
XXX
"She says I am a scientist, and I believe this to be true, I have a profound interest in the way things work."
I think a dash between true and I would help that sentence flow better than a comma.
XXX
"Even now I find myself wondering about the workings of this town, though I have no personal knowledge of my past my mind is filled with calculations and ideas that I itch to bring forth into the world."
Splitting this into two sentences at the comma would be better, I think.
XXX
"Hopefully when I am well I will be able to."
I think there should be a comma after "well" there. You also ended a sentence with a preposition, but honestly I can forgive that since this is a diary and he wouldn't be writing THAT formally.
XXX
"Skip ahead a few entries," said The Doctor, whatever happened it had to have been in recent years."
Misplaced quotation marks--it should read like this:
"Skip a head a few entries," said the Doctor. "Whatever happened, it had to have been in recent years." Unless that last part is a descriptor and not something the Doctor said aloud, in which case, ignore that and just delete the quotation mark at the end.
XXX
"Once again I must confide in you dear diary,"
Part of me THINKS there should be a comma after "you" there, but I'm not sure on this one.
XXX
"She has asked my help several times,"
Shouldn't that be FOR my help?
XXX
"Diary I must cite an odd happening this evening"
Comma after "Diary" and maybe at the end of that part, too.
XXX
"The door has been locked, I am afraid I have angered her quite thoroughly this time."
It would flow better if you put an "and" before "I am" or split those two into two sentences.
XXX
"It has been mere hours since my last entry, I find that I cannot sleep as nightmares plague my rest."
Again, put a "but" before "I" or separate those into two sentences. I think that'd work better.
XXX
"If only I could fathom there meaning, but alas I cannot."
Wrong "there" there--what you're looking for is "their."
XXX
"I must wonder if it is because she really requires my assistance. Or is simply trying to keep me busy, if Spike is correct, then I have been talking in my sleep"
I think that passage would flow better like this:
"I must wonder if it is because she really requires my assistance, or is simply trying to keep me busy. If Spike is correct, then I have been talking in my sleep."
XXX
"This apparently has her worried, is she trying to fill my mind by supplying me with other tasks so my dreams will turn to other subjects?"
Replace the comma between "worried" and "is" with a dash.
XXX
"The page following the entry were filled with more Sketches,"
I don't think sketches should be capitalized--unless everything made by The Doctor is capitalized. xP
XXX
"there are several of the devices currently in operation around ponyville."
And on the other hand, Ponyville SHOULD be capitalized. xD
XXX
"Magic for earthponies?"
Can earth ponies be spelled as just one word? Because I'm pretty sure it can't...but then again, I could be wrong here.
XXX
"A mere dream for many a young foal,"
I think there should only be one space between a and young...
XXX
"She has taken the invention to Cantolot"
Okay, I know that should be Canterlot, but on the other hand, that's kind of funny. I think that's where Pinkie Pie went to school and learned how to sing random songs out of nowhere. xP
XXX
"I write this in fear, Twilight has returned, and she has changed."
"I write this in fear." should be a sentence on its own.
XXX
"Spike seems just as worried, he has grown, almost too big for the library at this point."
Again, "Spike seems just as worried." should be a sentence on its own.
XXX
"I received a letter stating I have been summoned to Cantorlot, where I am to live,"
Not Canterlot? Well, he should be fine then. xP
Oh, and also, that should be its own sentence too. Otherwise it seems like a run-on.
XXX
"The opulence of Cantorlot is lost on me."
"Canterlot," again.
XXX
"I have never been far outside of the Library in Ponyville, Twilight never allowed me the pleasure, but in this darkness is there any point?"
I think that those would work best if they were separated into three sentences at the commas. Makes it sound more ominous.
XXX
"Dimond Dogs."
Remember, "Diamonds" are a girl's best friend.
XXX
"To the Lantern Castle in the Everfree,"
"The Everfree?" Sorry, it just sounds strange without the "Forest" at the end.
XXX
"Day and night are meaningless in anycase."
"any case."
XXX
"To continue, I have continued work on Twilight's newest tool of war."
That's a bit redundant. "To continue, I have continued." Is it really necessary to say "To continue" there? If you delete it, it'll make it flow better.
XXX
"they are my guards, and her insurance, they could devour me in seconds."
I think it would flow better if "They could devour me in seconds." was its own sentence, or at least the start of a new one, continuing at the "or"
XXX
"I am cautious, it may be some new agent of Twilight's power, sent to keep an eye on me."
Again, I think "I am cautious." should be its own sentence there.
XXX
"I had come out of the lab in order to have lunch, Fluttershy"
I think there should either be a dash there or again, a period.
XXX
"In anycase, I was eating as usual"
"any case"
XXX
"Apparently because Twilight has 'Become a meany.' which is the single biggest understatement I shall ever write."
No correction there, I just pointed it out because it made me laugh. Hard. xD
XXX
"I don't know how, or why this worked, but she said that there was only supposed to be one pony down there, so therefor if she was going down there with me willingly knowing what might happen, then she must not be a pony."
"therefore,"
XXX
"Now I find myself wondering....What is she?"
Not even The Doctor could ever hope to figure that out. But some of us like it that way.
XXX
"She is here, to check on my progress, queen Twilight has come here, and she is even less the mare I once knew than ever."
"Queen Twilight", and also, only one space is needed between even and less.
XXX
"Fluttershy is still nonethewiser."
I've never seen "none the wiser" spelled as one word before now, I have to say.
XXX
"In anycase, Pinkie and I have come up with a plan to stop her, a device which, when planted into the machine under the capital will disable it, and perhaps allow me time to make sure it never sees its terrible work done...for you see Twilight has ruined one world...I shall not let her ruin another."
Okay, several things there. First off, there's the "any case" again. Then, I think there should be another comma before "will disable it." Also, I don't know if The Doctor writes in his own dramatic pauses, but if not, "For you see" and "I shall not" shouldn't have ellipses before them. If you want to add a pause, you should probably move the "I shall not let her ruin another." a line down.
XXX
And in the paragraph after that, I don't think all the ellipses were necessary either, but they do work to set the tone, so I'll ignore that.
XXX
Twilight Sparkle, master of the Hannibal Lecture. And that's why I love her. xD
XXX
Other than that, I don't think there's anything else to correct. And I have to say, by the end, I was jumping up and down like Trixie in my head. This is so exciting! I really need to finish my MLP story soon, but I want to see the ending to this WAY more than that. Thank you for writing such a great story, and I assure you, I wouldn't help you out if I didn't believe it has massive potential.
👍: 0 ⏩: 0